Best Felt Tip Eyeliners for Perfect Wing & Cat-Eyes



by Lydia


No Comments

Basically, there are two types of people in the world: people who prefer liquid liners and those who simply don't. If you identify as the former, then this piece is for you, at your service. However, if you swing more towards the latter and maybe a little skeptical, we have faith that the best felt-tip eyeliners will convert you to the dark side of sleek, edgy cat eyes.

Applying liquid eyeliner to create a sleek cat-eye look still remains one of the most challenging and most inestimable beauty feats. When working with a hard-to-handle fussy formula, you'll need swabs of cotton and a whole lot of makeup remover on hand.

But we won't always have the surplus of time or patience to go through this every morning. So this is a really great place to start on the long list of reasons why we should stick to formulas that we can trust to perform well.

In a hurry?
This is our Winner!

Our Pick

 What is the best felt tip eyeliner?

What Are the Types of Liquid Liners?

Eye makeup in the form of liquid eyeliner comes in a few different forms, and the main ones are:

a) Liquid Brush-tip Eyeliners

These are pretty good if you need to get close to your lash line. You can get them in the form of waterproof eyeliner for voluminous lashes and lash growth. However, this waterproof liquid brush tip eye makeup will need some time to learn, especially for the really pigmented brush tip liquid liners. They also require a somewhat steady hand. Otherwise, it can be a little hard to master.

b) Liquid Felt-tip Eyeliners

Felt-tip eyeliners are quite similar to the brush-tip eyeliners, but unlike the brush-tip, they're much easier to taper off a thin line for a sharp wing, and with these, you're assured of precise lines that will always come out as smoothly.

c) Gel-pot Eyeliners

The best gel-pot eyeliners have a highly pigmented formula and won't need any building up. So if you don't have a Japanese precision brush tip with lots of control, it'll be hard to get the smooth line.

Why Use Felt-Tip Eyeliners?

  • Felt-tip eyeliners help draw an ultra-fine line on your lids and come in handy if you are a beginner. It has a precise applicator which will help avoid a mess
  • A felt tip eyeliner gives you more control and helps define your eyes in relatively less time, which comes in handy, especially when you're in a rush
  • Felt-tip eyeliners have everything you'll need in one
  • It comes in a travel-friendly packaging
  • The felt-tip liner has a soft and precise tip that easily glides to give you a thin or thick, or catchy cat-eye

How To Use A Felt-tip Eyeliner?

Here's how you use a felt-tip eyeliner like a pro:

  • Prep the liner by shaking it then removing the cap to expose it tip eyeliner applicator
  • Position the felt-tip into the inner corner side of the eyes, then begin with a small thin stroke and make it thicker as you continue
  • From the inner corner, continue to line it using the lash liner with short but thin line strokes
  • Extend the thin line past your lash line to draw more precise and bold wings

With a high-quality felt-tip eyeliner helps you perfectly draw thin or thick lines on your lashes. The best felt-tip eyeliners come as waterproof liquid eyeliners that are smudge-proof and glide over, creating a smooth line. You only need to draw a thin line like you would while using a marker pen.

[amazon fields="B0031NNE56" value="thumb"]

This Stila waterproof eyeliner pick is a makeup cult favorite, all thanks to its thin felt tip that easily glides, is easy to control, deposits just the right amount of fluid —and, of course, it's an all-day stay eye makeup. In addition, it has a matte finish that won't feather, smudge, or run. As a result, it has been the perfect go-to if you want to create the perfect cat eye for years now.

It comes in jet black and is available in a decent number of dreamy muted shades, like deep blue and espresso brown. The Stila All Day waterproof liquid eyeliner helps to create steady strokes of thin to thick lines for an edgy look. Its unique waterproof gel-formula glides smoothly on your eyelid and dries pretty quick to leave your eye tips defined.

The marker-like fine tip gives you a precise application and can easily stay on for roughly 8-10 hours. It has a perfectly sized felt tip that sets smoothly without pulling, smudging, or skipping for a velvety smooth application, with budge-proof durability and impeccable color spread.

Key Features:

  • Type: Felt-tip pen
  • Shades: 6 options
  • Free of: OilS and Sulfates
  • Cruelty-free: Yes


  • Easy-to-control felt-tip applicator
  • Long-wear stay
  • Available in 6 different shades
  • Smudge-proof
  • Highly pigmented


  • It dries out pretty fast, which can be a little difficult for beginners to use

The Maybelline Eyestudio gel eyeliner is a high-quality drugstore. It has plenty of positive feedback, so you can rest assured that the gel waterproof formula is worth every penny.

The felt-tip eyeliner is in a gel formula that's made using an innovative Ink technology to give you a pigment saturated matte finish throughout the day. In addition, the smudge-proof makeup formula doesn't pull to ensure that your smokey tips stay in place without the need for reapplications or touchups.

Key Features:

  • Type:  Waterproof long-wearing gel formula
  • Shades: 3
  • Free of: Parabens
  • Cruelty-Free: No
  • Byrdie Clean: No


  • Long-wear stay
  • Waterproof
  • Available in different shades other than black
  • Easy-to-control felt-tip applicator


  • Not as many shades options

Another waterproof drugstore eyeliner that ranks high since it's from the Revlon ColorStay line. It gives you an impressive 16-hour staying power that dries up pretty quick. What's more, it doesn't smudge, pull or smear mid your application.

This waterproof liquid eye liner comes with a flexible applicator that makes creating any cat-eye or wing look so much easier. The formulation is ophthalmologist-tested and deemed safe for people with sensitive eyes and those who contact lenses. This is one of the best felt-tip eyeliners for you if you're concerned about any eye irritation or burning sensation if you happen to slip accidentally.

Key Features:

  • Type: Waterproof felt-tip pen
  • Shades: 1 option
  • Free of: Sulfates and oil


  • Long-wearing stay
  • Dries up pretty quick
  • Tested by ophthalmologist


  • Doesn't come in as many shades as other options

Generally, a felt-tip eyeliner would need more precision and practice, but the L'Oréal Paris liquid eyeliner is the perfect place for beginners to start. It comes with an easy-to-apply felt-tip liquid liner.

This liner formula has a long-staying power that's smooth and perfect for trying out different makeup applications and looks that won't cost you a fortune. In addition, the smudge-proof formula can last you up to 12 hours, making it a perfect pick for your everyday wear. This top-rated liquid liner formula is also only available in black, grey, and brown, out of which you can find the best shade that compliments your eyes.

Key Features:

  • Type: Felt-tip eyeliner pen
  • Shades: 3 options
  • Free of: Parabens and oil


  • Easy-to-apply felt-tip application
  • Long-wearing stay
  • Dries pretty quickly


  • Don't have as many shades options

The FENTY BEAUTY Flyliner longwear is hyper-saturated and water-resistant liquid eyeliner. It has everything and more that you'd want from the makeup felt-tip liner. With its intelligent triangular-shaped design that's easy to hold, it features a super-flex felt-tip that's exclusive to FENTY BEAUTY.

This tip allows you a smooth, uninterrupted water-resistant ink flow from different angles. Its tapered shape allows you to get a little creative with the thickness of your line. By delivering the color intensity of a liquid eyeliner with the smooth glide of a gel.

Key Features:

  • Type: Felt-tip eyeliner pen
  • Shades: 1 option
  • Free of: Parabens and oil
  • Cruelty-Free: Yes


  • Easy to hold design
  • Water-resistant makeup formulation
  • Super-flex felt-tip applicator
  • Great color payoff


  • Only available in one color, black

What to Consider for the Best Felt Tip Eyeliners?

A) What's the Texture?

When it comes to choosing the best liquid, felt tip liner, always consider the texture to help you find what's best suited for your desired look and skill level. Essentially, a cream formula dries relatively slower, so you'd have more time to adjust anything you needed to.

The liquid felt tip eyeliners in pen form dries instantly, but on the good side, it allows you to achieve sharper for more precise lines. Consider the felt tip liquid pen if you want to achieve a more graphic eyeliner look, but try the cream if you don't have such steady hands or are yet to perfect your cat-eye.

B) Are You Ready for It?

Another factor you'll have to consider for this kind of applicator is what level you're at. Liquid eyeliner always comes in different applicators that vary from product to product. For example, some eyeliners come in the form of a felt tip pen with a fine tip, while others come with built-in brushes.

Both applicators are great when you need to achieve particular looks. Although felt tip eyeliners in pen formats come with a sharp-tipped pen, it's a lot easier for a beginner with a steady hand to control. With enough practice, you'll have more control for a smudge-proof and perfect cat-eye.

C) What's the Intensity?

Typically, liquid liners are used to create a bolder look than the pencil eyeliner could achieve. Always consider the intensity of the felt tip eyeliner formula before making your purchase. Most people will go for a rich, deep jet black liner. Generally, the deeper and the more vibrant the liner's intensity is, the better the liner is. Since liners also come in many different colors, you'll want the best-felt tip that's richly pigmented to help you pop. 

Frequently Asked Questions on the Best Felt Tip Eyeliners

1. Is it better to use felt tip eyeliners?

Thanks to its marker-esque design, a felt tip eyeliner is typically preferred when you need to create that dramatic cat-eye. The perfect eyeliner glides effortlessly with the accurate application to give you bold, precise lines for a smudge-proof and dramatic flair.

With enough practice, you'll be doing a spectacular job on the cat eyes, and they will also become more accessible. However, not having enough practice using a liquid eyeliner pen could have you end up with messy thick lines as you try to even out the liner tip on both eyes.

2. Should you wear black or brown eyeliner?

If you have brown eyes, then opt for a brown felt tip eyeliner for a more natural look. A brown felt tip eyeliner would give you a soft dimension to the tips making them seem rich and intense. However, a jet black felt tip eyeliner will always be the best choice for a sharp and sleek look.

3. Is the gel felt tip liner better than the liquid?

The best-felt tip gel formulas are best for beginners who struggle to draw the cat-eye wings using liquid liners. You can easily correct the mistakes you've made with a gel liner much more quickly than you would with a liquid liner. Ideally, it's more pliable, and you have much more room to fix stuff because it also doesn't set as fast.

4. Is it safe to use a felt tip eyeliner on the waterline?

The eyes are a pretty sensitive area, so it'd make sense that it could irritate if you apply eyeliner so close to your eyes. Liquid eyeliners aren't meant to be used on your waterline in the first place.

However, you can use it to line your lash line. As for your waterline, makeup experts recommend that you use a pencil with a formula that's specifically intended for such a sensitive part of the eye.

5. What is the reverse cat eye?

A reverse cat-eye tip is exactly what it sounds like. Ideally, it's an upside-down version of the traditional wing-tip. However, instead of only applying the eyeliner on your upper lash line, you also apply it along your lower lash line. The wing pretty much stays the same.


Leave a Comment